Episodes

We're back with another special episode this week! Since the whole I Should Have Known crew is in India to celebrate Holi, we thought we'd embrace the nostalgia and remaster our season 2 episode on the festival of color! Even...

We're continuing our 90s throwback theme this week with a look at the gadgets that defined the decade! Quizmaster Sups brings the nostalgia with four electronics that came out in the 1990s, except one of them is out of place....

Attention '90s kids: this whole month is for you! To start off our nostalgiac trip down memory lane, Quizmaster Tanner recounted four facts from 90s cartoons. But one of them is actually a total lie! How well do you remember …

In this extra special episode, we're giving all our listeners a peek behind the scenes! Every month, we discuss what went into making each episode, the extra content that wound up on the cutting room floor, and bonus facts th...

This one goes out to all the lonely hearts out there! To continue with our theme of Anti-Valentines, Quizmaster Tanner analyzed four studies on loneliness, but one of his takeaways is false! Do you think you can spot the lie …

This week we're continuing our love of anti-love with our Anti-Valentines theme! Quizmaster Sups queued up four facts about break up songs, but one of them will break your heart. See if you can figure out which fact is a …

Happy Anti-Valentine's Month! For February, we're celebrating the opposite of love. To kick it off, Quizmaster Andi lovingly scrounged through history for four traditions of divorce. But one of them is made up! How deep is yo...

To wrap up our Animal Kingdom month, Quizmaster Tanner wrangled together four facts on house cats! But one of his facts might scratch you if you come in for cuddles, since it's 100% false! If you're feline lucky, take a …

As we continue marching along with this month's Animal Kingdom theme, we're pulling out our magnifying glasses to take a close look at ants! Quizmaster Sups dug up four facts about different ant species. But one of the facts ...

Stand at attention and listen in to our next episode in our Animal Kingdom theme! Quizmaster Andi took a peek at creatures around the world for four facts about their reproductive organs. But one of them is ... impotent. Thin...

We're continuing with our Animal Kingdom theme for this month, so Quizmaster Tanner selected protected species from the IUCN endangered species list and delivered four big facts about them. But one of these facts is 100% fals...

Happy New Year! To celebrate a new year and a new month, we're exploring the animal kingdom with episodes dedicated to our furry, feathery, scaly friends! Quizmaster Sups is starting off with a safari of four national animals...

To conclude our December theme, Quizmaster Andi surveyed the frigid cosmos for four icy worlds. But one of the celestial bodies she describes is from a fictional universe! Listen in as hosts Tanner and Sups do their best to s...

Fill up your cup for this episode all about beverages that folks drink in December! Continuing our theme of "December," Quizmaster Tanner found four recipes for drinks from around the world. But one of them is fake! Join host...

Happy December! We're continuing our theme with end-of-the-year staples like Hallmark Christmas movies! Quizmaster and cheesy film connoisseur Andi screened four Christmas movies from the Hallmark Channel, but one of them is ...

I Should Have Known is celebrating all month long! Our theme for December is... December! Kicking off the festivities is Quizmaster Sups, who discovered four festivals which are celebrated in December. Except we're late to th...

We're finishing up our spotlight on Asia month this week! In this special episode, Quizmaster Andi attempts to fool the Indian about India! She presents four Hindu deities but one is completely a false god. Do you think you c...

Who's that Pokemon?! For this week's episode in our Spotlight on Asia theme, Quizmaster and Pokemon Master Tanner caught four off-the-wall creatures from Japan. But one of them was his own creation! Think you can catch 'em al...

Dig in to this mouth-watering episode continuing our Spotlight on Asia theme! This week, Quizmaster Andi whipped up four delicious (?) servings of dumplings from around Asia. But one of them is completely fake! Do you think y...

Welcome to Asia! This month we're shining a light on the continent of Asia and to begin, Quizmaster Sups is exploring the country of Sri Lanka. He has discovered four big facts about the nation, but one of them is …

Happy Halloween! To conclude our Stranger Than Fiction theme, Quizmaster Tanner unearthed four spooky stories from H.P. Lovecraft that are sure to send a chill down your spine. But keep your wits about you, because one of the...

Join another eerie episode in our Stranger Than Fiction theme for Halloween! This time, Quizmaster Andi went "Beyond Bigfoot" to bring out four cryptid creatures from around the world. But be on the lookout: one of the four a...

Continuing our Stranger Than Fiction theme for Halloween, Quizmaster Tanner lined up four true crime podcasts. But one of them is a completely fake podcast that investigates a fictional crime! Our fearless hosts, Andi and Sup...

We're keeping it creepy this month with another Stranger Than Fiction episode! Quizmaster Sups introduces four dangerous games played around the world. But three of the games have been ripped from the realms of fiction, while...